90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
PLEDGE NOW
Here and Now with Robin Young
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Thursday, February 7, 2013

The Ethics Of Prolonging Life, Or Pulling The Plug

Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon speaks during a press conference at his Jerusalem office November 2005. Seven years after a devastating stroke, Sharon remains in a coma. (Emilio Morenatti/AP)

Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon speaks during a press conference at his Jerusalem office in November 2005. Seven years after a devastating stroke, Sharon remains in a coma. (Emilio Morenatti/AP)

Former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon has been in a permanent vegetative state since suffering a stroke in January 2006. But recently in tests he showed signs of brain activity.

Doctors performed brain scans on the 84-year-old Sharon while showing him pictures of random houses. When they flashed a picture of his own home, Sharon’s brain images lit up.

Sharon’s brain also responded to family voices, but not other sounds.

Does that mean Ariel Sharon is “in there” – conscious in a body that can’t move? And what does all of this mean for patients and families in similar situations?

Bioethicist Art Caplan, who heads the Division of Medical Ethics at New York University’s Langone Medical Center, says the brain test results do not mean that Sharon will wake up.

And prolonging the life of Sharon – and others like him – may be causing misery, Caplan said, if he has any awareness of being trapped in his body.

How would you decide if/when to remove life support? Let us know in the comments or join the debate on our Facebook page.

Guest:


Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
  • rogger2

    Amen Caplan!
    I couldn’t agree with you more.  

  • Pat Terry

    The most compassionat way of allowing A body to die in peace is to guide the soul beyond.
    Let the soul soar on to Its next incarnation.  Release the soul to spirit!

  • Hirsch21n@yahoo.com

    Mr Caplan, I take great exception of even the thought of as you say pulling the plug on Prime Minister Sharon. You say he may be in misery hell he just may not be!!! I don’t believe he has any pain at all. G-d is taking care of Ariel and will till till it is his time to leave us !!! has come. My hope is that he comes out of his sleep to be with his sons again. DON’T YOU EVER FORGET MR. CAPLAN, ARIEL IS THE REAL KING OF ISRAEL AND WILL BE FOREVER.I LOVE HIM WITH ALL MY HEART, PlEASE COME BACK TO US MYGREAT KING, WE ALL MISS YOU S MUCH. REGARDS, Lionel Hirsch Sydney n.s

Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

April 15 7 Comments

4 Lamb Recipes, Plus Lamb Cooking Tips

With the weather getting warmer, Here & Now resident chef Kathy Gunst is thinking lamb. She shares recipes for Middle Eastern-style lamb meatballs and more.

April 15 14 Comments

The Problem With U.S. Tax Policies

Tax expert David Cay Johnston says it's easy to fool the IRS, but there's one catch: "you have to be rich." He says outdated tax policies are hurting the economy.

April 14 4 Comments

Lessons For News Media After Marathon Bombings

We take a look at what the news media got wrong and what can be learned for future breaking news coverage.

April 14 8 Comments

Marathon Bombing Survivor Loses Limbs But Finds New Life

A year after Jeff Bauman lost both legs in the bombing, he and his fiancée are expecting their first child.