90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
Here and Now with Robin Young
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Monday, March 24, 2014

A Trick For Bending The Laws Of Physics

You see it on T.V. all the time: cops interrogating a suspect in a cramped room while prosecutors watch from the other side of a one-way mirror.

The prosecutors can see in, but the suspects can’t see out.

Those mirrors are specially coated and lighting is used to create the one-way illusion.

Now engineers at the University of Texas in Austin have figured out how to create a one-way illusion with sound.

From the Here & Now Contributors Network, Matt Largey of KUT in Austin explains.




Well, staying in Texas now. You see it on TV all the time: cops interrogating a suspect in a cramped room while prosecutors watch from the other side of a one-way mirror. The prosecutors can see in, but the suspects can't see out.


MARGO MARTINDALE: (As Rita Gabler) Everything we did, we did out of love.

LEO BURMESTER: (As Bud Gabler) Don't say anything else, Rita.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (As character) But those are your voices. You call her by name. You still don't know her?

BURMESTER: (As Bud Gabler) Where did our lawyer go?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (As character) You don't know those?

BURMESTER: (As Bud Gabler) Where did our lawyer go?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (As character) Let me play it again.

BURMESTER: (As Bud Gabler) We're not saying another word till she gets here. Not another word.

HOBSON: Well, those mirrors are especially coated and lighting is used to create the one-way illusion. But now engineers at the University of Texas, Austin have figured out how to create a one-way illusion with sound. From the HERE AND NOW Contributors Network, KUT's Matt Largey explains.

MATT LARGEY, BYLINE: So waves of energy behave in very specific ways. That's just the way it is. And the behavior we're talking about here, it has to do with how waves move between two points. It's called reciprocity.

ANDREA ALU: It actually is a general law of physics for which most materials have what is called time reversal symmetry.

LARGEY: That's Andrea Alu. He is an engineering professor UT Austin. Anyway, this time reversal symmetry.

ALU: That means that if I can send a wave down a path, then the wave should be able to come back.

LARGEY: Right. So I'm on one side of a space. You're on the other side. I shout to you. Hey. You hear it, and you can shout back. Hey. And I hear it. The sound waves can move through the air in both directions. It's reciprocal.


ALU: Most waves in most materials like sound, light, radio waves, they (unintelligible).

ROMAIN FLEURY: But there are a lot of situations in which you don't like this property.

LARGEY: That's Romain Fleury.

FLEURY: I am an international graduate student in electrical computer engineering.

LARGEY: And he wanted to find a way to eliminate reciprocity.

FLEURY: So what we want to do is isolate sound to create a one-way road for sound.


FLEURY: We want that when somebody talk, for instance, I talk to you. It's just a sound test, right?

LARGEY: Yeah. Yeah.

FLEURY: OK. You can hear me. So I don't know. But if you talk, I don't want to hear you.


FLEURY: It sounds rude, but that's what we are trying to do.

LARGEY: Simple concept, but it means breaking a fundamental law of physics. And that is complicated.

FLEURY: It's a tough problem because physics doesn't allow that at all. It's against it.

LARGEY: It's hard to argue with physics too.

FLEURY: Yeah. It's very hard.


LARGEY: Fleury and his team worked on this problem for months. They tried all kinds of things. And then...

FLEURY: One night...

LARGEY: In the lab, Fleury tried something new.

FLEURY: And it just worked right away, like first simulation. I think the simulation took two minutes.

LARGEY: Here's how he did it. He built a ring.

FLEURY: Yeah, it's a ring cavity, so it's carved in an aluminum block.

LARGEY: So it's like the inside of a hollow aluminum donut.

FLEURY: And then this ring is connected to three pipes.

LARGEY: OK. Where are my pipes?


LARGEY: All right. There we go. Now, they're sticking off the ring in a kind of triangle shape. Three pipes.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) One.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: (Singing) Two.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #4: (Singing) Three.

UNIDENTIFIED MEN: (Singing) Three pipes.

LARGEY: Yes, exactly.

FLEURY: And you can send sound from one pipe, it goes into the ring and leaves by another pipe.

LARGEY: Now, by itself the sound would go in one pipe. Let's say pipe one.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) One.

LARGEY: It travels around the ring to come out pipes two and three.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) Two.

LARGEY: Right?

FLEURY: Yeah. It would be split.

LARGEY: But then Fleury did something that sounds super simple. He put a fan in the ring.

FLEURY: You put computer fans inside.

LARGEY: Just a regular, off-the-shelf fan you'd find in a computer.

FLEURY: And you rotate the air inside, along the ring.

LARGEY: At a very specific speed and angle. Now try pipe one again.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) One.

FLEURY: It goes into the ring and leaves by another pipe.

LARGEY: Out of pipe two.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) Two.

FLEURY: But if you send sound back from this other pipe...

LARGEY: Back into pipe two.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) Two.

FLEURY: ...it doesn't go back to the first one. It goes to the third one.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Singing) Three.

LARGEY: And only the third one. The sound moves one way between the pipes now.

ALU: I have one, two, but not two, one. I have two, three, but not three, two. And I have three, one, but not one, three.

LARGEY: They broke the rules, or at least they bent the rules. A very specific way of moving the air with the fans - what they call angular momentum bias - allows sound to move one way, but not the other. In other words, nonreciprocally.

ALU: Essentially the signals always flow in the way contrary to the airflow spin.

LARGEY: Pretty cool stuff, but also it's like, how simple is that?

DR. STEVEN CUMMER: I know what you mean because you're right. What they built is deceptively simple looking.

LARGEY: That's Dr. Steven Cummer. He studies wave manipulation at Duke University.

CUMMER: But you have to give them a lot of credit that it's a very simple structure, but it also does exhibit some very fundamental physics in it. And nobody had demonstrated it before or thought to use it to demonstrate something as fundamental in wave physics as nonreciprocity.

LARGEY: As simple as it sounds, no one had ever figured it out before. So the question is, now that they've figured it out, what do you do with it?

FLEURY: So it could be like the acoustic equivalent of a one-way glass. So you can hear somebody through the glass, but they cannot hear you.

LARGEY: Better noise cancellation is one potential. But people who work on this stuff are pretty pumped about this discovery for another reason - because you might be able to apply this basic concept to all kinds of waves, not just sound. Maybe things like radio waves or...

ALU: We may be able to extend these same concepts to light.

LARGEY: And that would be a big deal because super fast computer chips that use light instead of electrical pulses are already being developed. And a cheap way to make a one-way path for light in those chips would be a huge leap for that technology. And it might help get them to market faster, eventually. For now, that sound that you aren't hearing could be the harbinger of big things to come. For HERE AND NOW, I'm Matt Largey.

HOBSON: The kinds of stories you can only really do on the radio. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
  • The_Truth_Seeker

    There’s no “bending” the laws of physics. There are just ways of using those laws to result in something not normally found in nature (like lasers, reactors & atomic bombs). That’s the really interesting and great thing about physics+intelligence. You can end up with lots of things not normally (or easily) found in nature. It’s as close as you can get to what used to be called alchemy, while still not violating the laws of nature. That helps to make science endlessly fun!

  • MountainK1ng

    They may be able to extend this concept to other physical wave phenomena, but I don’t see a corollary for extending this concept to light and other electromagnetic waves. The difference is that sound is a wave in a medium. They achieved this effect through a disruption of the medium. Light is not a wave in a medium, light IS the wave. There is no medium to manipulate. Light can travel through a vacuum.

    A skeptical physicist.

    • The_Truth_Seeker

      If you “talk” to a black hole using light waves, you’re not going to be able to hear it talking back (ignoring Hawking radiation for now). Also any wave travels through a field, so if you want to think of the field as a non-material medium, then light does travel through this field (consistent with relativity). Remember, even “empty” space is not really empty (in the quantum sense), otherwise a universe could never have come about.

  • Old Timer

    I’m struck how similar in function this is to a device employed in electronics for decades; I knew it as a “circulator” although it may have gone by other names. Most commonly these were 3-port devices also and as with this audio version, the basic function was that there would be a high degree of coupling between certain ports in one direction and a high degree of isolation between ports in the reverse direction. These were often found in transmitters or more importantly in
    transceivers: a unit that could transmit and receive simultaneously. So one port was the transmitter’s output, a second was the receiver’s input, and the third was the antenna. Thus a single antenna would receive signals from the transmitter but also provide signals to the receiver; meanwhile the transmitter was isolated from the receiver. I encountered them mostly in devices operating in the near-1GHz frequency range but they existed for most any frequency (but any one circulator could only function for a very narrow frequency range). I’m very rusty on details and won’t claim I understood then well anyway. But f I recall correctly, they also depended on a “magic” assist, only instead of air fans it was a magnetic field, which was usually a simple magnet built into the device. Although my experience was circulators based on coaxial cable technology, I believe there were wave-guide versions as well. So I’m pretty confident I can state this has been applied to radio waves for a long time already.
    As for light: prior to retirement I spent much less time in this domain but in some ways I would be surprised if this hasn’t already been done. However, I can’t state it for fact, and wonder if again a “magic” assistant is needed; perhaps simple polarization.

  • A Physics Student

    Reciprocity has not been broken, as is claimed, in this case. A physical system, without energy loss, will always be reversible in time. To test this system in reverse, the fan has to also be run in reverse, in which case the sound should travel the reverse path. However, it is still an intersting achievement.

    • The_Truth_Seeker

      Except for 2nd law of thermodynamics. For energy conservative mechanical systems time reversal symmetry is basically true (unless it is a highly unstable system, such as a random three or more body system acted on by gravity – it’s motion is usually not repeated, therefore it can’t be time-reversed).

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-symmetry (not bad)

Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

August 18 33 Comments

More Americans Are Flocking To The South

A New York Times interpretation of census data finds the South is seeing significant in-migration for the first time.

August 18 10 Comments

As Pot Laws Relax, Restrictions On Research Still Tight

The firing of a University of Arizona doctor highlights the complexity and politics of marijuana research.

August 15 8 Comments

Facing Backlash, SeaWorld Expands Killer Whale Habitats

SeaWorld has faced criticism over its treatment of captive killer whales since the release of the documentary, "Blackfish."

August 15 9 Comments

Training Police To Put Aside Their Biases

Criminologist Lorie Fridell says police officers can and should be trained to recognize their own internal biases.