90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
Here and Now with Robin Young
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Schools Look For Higher Bar With Common Core, But Are The Tests Too Hard?

Students take a quiz in Eric Miller's eighth grade algebra class at Lakes Magnet Middle School in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho. (Jessica Robinson/Northwest News Network)

Students take a quiz in Eric Miller’s eighth grade algebra class at Lakes Magnet Middle School in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho. (Jessica Robinson/Northwest News Network)

Parents of school-aged children in more than 20 states have a new acronym to learn: The SBAC. The Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium is the new standardized test that’s set to replace current state math and language arts tests.

It’s billed as the “next generation” of assessment — a test that hopes to capture students’ abilities with more depth than traditional standardized tests.

From the Here & Now Contributors Network, Jessica Robinson reports from Idaho that some critics say the new test runs into the same old problems.


  • Jessica Robinson, inland Northwest correspondent for Northwest News Network, reporting from the bureau in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho. She tweets @N3jessica.



It's HERE AND NOW. Parents of school-age children in more than 20 states have a new acronym to learn: SBAC, S-B-A-C. That's the new standardized test that's set to replace current state math and language arts tests. It's billed as the next generation of assessment, a test that hopes to capture students' abilities with more depth than traditional standardized tests.

But from the HERE AND NOW contributors network, Jessica Robinson reports from Idaho that some critics say the new test runs into the same old problems.

JESSICA ROBINSON, BYLINE: The SBAC stands for the Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium, a group of 24 states, and last year, hundreds of schools - including many in the Northwest - got their first taste of what the new test is like. Seventh graders at Lakes Magnet Middle School in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, filed into the computer lab in the school's library for the test.

RYAN GILLESPIE: This whole thing was full. In fact, I think we even had computers on this side. It was a big room. There was a lot of clicking going on.

ROBINSON: Ryan Gillespie is a math coach for the district. And this new test, Gillespie said, had been talked about for years.

GILLESPIE: I mean, it was almost becoming lore. This new test was going to be very difficult. And we were just excited to see if the myths were true.

ROBINSON: Now, the pilot didn't go off without a hitch. The online test was sluggish at times. The dragging and highlighting functions didn't work so well. But Gillespie says the questions themselves were noticeably different. Here's an example: In the past, students might be given an equation.

GILLESPIE: You know, 3x + 1 = 9.

ROBINSON: And asked to solve for x.

GILLESPIE: And the kids go, OK, do a minus one here, and a minus one there.

ROBINSON: Divide both sides by three, and x = 2 2/3. Are you following this?

GILLESPIE: So it's an if I do this, I do this, then do this, and I circle my answer, and I'm done.

But, he says, the student might not understand what that two and two thirds means, or why it's x. On the SBAC, Gillespie says kids might still have to solve for x, but they were also asked questions like this.

Here's the equation, 3x + 1 = 9, and here's five different real-world scenarios. Which of these five scenarios could be modeled using this equation? So, kids have to understand that mathematical sentence, that language, understand conceptually what it means. And it was something we've never been evaluated on.

ROBINSON: The SBAC is designed to accomplish something that parents and teachers have long sought: an assessment aimed at measuring critical thinking. The test includes multiple choice questions, but also more complex performance tasks where students have to take in information and give a long-form answer. Schools will be able to see how they stack up to other states and track year-to-year student growth from grade 3 on.

Mike Nelson is director of curriculum and assessment for the Coeur d'Alene School District. He says parents may see proficiency levels go down at first, because students are being asked to clear a higher bar.

MIKE NELSON: In my history as an assessment guy, this is a much different test than what we've seen before. And it's a better test. We want kids, yes, that have requisite knowledge, but we want them to apply and use this information for their betterment.

ROBINSON: The test is tied to the new, more rigorous Common Core standards in math, reading and writing that most states have adopted. Those standards have proven contentious among some parents and politicians, but among educators, it's not the standards, it's the tests that are more controversial.

At a recent hearing in the Idaho legislature, Bruce Cook, a curriculum director from Rexburg, Idaho, said kids as young as eight and nine may not have the computer skills to take the SBAC.

BRUCE COOK: We have had to put money and time into keyboarding. We didn't have a keyboarding program for third and fourth graders. I don't know that most schools did. But we surely didn't.

ROBINSON: One poll found only 27 percent of teachers in Idaho support the SBAC. Some schools say the test is just too hard and too long. The SBAC isn't timed, but it's expected to range from six hours in total for elementary schoolers, up to seven-and-a-half hours for older students.

Kansas dropped out of the Smarter Balanced consortium late last year to create its own test. Alaska plans to follow. And there are rumblings about doing the same in Idaho. Education researcher Amy Roth McDuffie says the biggest problem isn't about the SBAC itself or any test aligned to the Common Core standards. It's how much value teachers, districts and even the state put on the test.

McDuffie teaches at Washington State University. Last year, she coauthored a report based on surveys of middle school math teachers. It found most teachers planned to use the test as a guide for classroom instruction, in part because the test weighs so heavily on teachers' own evaluations.

AMY ROTH MCDUFFIE: My concerns, then, are if the focus so much from teachers is on seeing the test - and it's understandable that they take that stance - then are we really aiming to teach to the Common Core, or are we teaching to a test, and what can easily be tested?

ROBINSON: McDuffie worries the Common Core standards states have crafted so carefully could ultimately be less important than a single test. But Ryan Gillespie, the math instructor in Coeur d'Alene, has a different view of it. He says teaching to this test, if that's what happens, wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing.

GILLESPIE: Math has always been something that's much more dynamic to me than just memorizing procedures. And so when I was watching this test, and I was seeing what kids were having to do, to me, I was thrilled, because it was - the questions were requiring kids to use the skills that - why I got into math in the first place.

ROBINSON: This spring, teachers and students in 22 states will get to experience the full test for the first time. Schools are running a field test of the SBAC, a kind of test of the test. And for this year only, the results won't count. For HERE AND NOW, I'm Jessica Robinson in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho.

YOUNG: And you can take a practice version of the SBAC yourself at hereandnow.org. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

October 22 13 Comments

Colorado Backs Away From Pot Edibles Ban

Critics say a ban would violate the state's voter-approved legalization of recreational marijuana, which took effect in January.

October 22 4 Comments

Modest Raise For Social Security Recipients

Economist Diane Swonk says the 1.7 percent cost-of-living increase falls short of the inflation older Americans actually see.

October 21 Comment

Jim Gaffigan’s Love Affair With Food

The stand-up comic gives his particular gastronomic take on the world in his new memoir "Food: A Love Story."

October 21 Comment

Jill Abramson Announces Plans For News Startup

The former New York Times executive editor said her goal is to create a news outlet that favors quality over quantity.