90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
Here and Now with Robin Young
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Verdi Vs. Wagner, And Why They Disliked Each Other’s Music

German composer Richard Wagner, left, and Italian composer Giuseppe Verdi, right, would both be turning 200 years old in 2013. (Wikimedia Commons)

German composer Richard Wagner, left, and Italian composer Giuseppe Verdi, right, would both be turning 200 years old in 2013. (Wikimedia Commons)

There have been documentaries and celebrations for 100 years since the premiere of The Rite of Spring, but this year also would be the 200th birthday of the opera composers Giuseppe Verdi and Richard Wagner.

Verdi, who was Italian, wrote operas that are continually performed by major opera companies. His most famous works include “Aida” and “La Traviata,” about a woman who must decide whether she loves a man enough to give up her carefree ways.

Wagner was a German composer with a much more checkered life. He was usually in debt, he was an anti-Semite, he was a womanizer, and yet he composed operas of staggering creativity and ambition. Most famous among these are the cycle of four operas collectively known as “The Ring Cycle,” and “Tristan und Isolde,” about two doomed lovers.

“Wagner was known to abhor grand opera. And Verdi was known to say that Wagner often went down an avenue that was unnecessary.”
– William Lumpkin

Not fans of each other’s work

It goes without saying that although both Verdi and Wagner wrote operas, their operas sounded very different. And it turns out, they weren’t each other’s biggest fans.

“It’s interesting to me that these guys were contemporaries of each other,” said William Lumpkin, the director of the Opera Institute at Boston University. “According to what I know, they actually never met, but they certainly knew of each other, and perhaps didn’t have the greatest respect for what each other was doing. Wagner was known to abhor grand opera. And Verdi was known to say that Wagner often went down an avenue that was unnecessary.”

It’s still a common criticism of Wagner — that his operas are long-winded and bombastic.

Verdi’s opera style

So what does grand opera — the opera tradition that Wagner abhorred, and in which Verdi came from — sound like?

“Italian opera was really written with the singers in mind,” explained Lumpkin. This meant operas showed off singers’ skills, and included beautiful, soaring melodies. The singing style itself is called “bel canto,” which translates to “beautiful singing.”

Lumpkin summarizes it this way: “Italian opera — and opera in general — was for entertainment purposes. People came, they heard the singer, the singer hit the high note, applause.”

  • Renée Fleming performs in Verdi’s “La Traviata,” Los Angeles Opera, 2006

Wagner’s opera style

This was very different from how Wagner viewed opera. He thought of opera as a “social ritual in which people came together to witness this huge, massive scope of an artistic venture,” Lumpkin said.

This is the idea Wagner called “Gesamkuntswerk,” which translates to the total art work. “All things coming together for one objective,” Lumkpin said.

Gesamkuntswerk meant that Wagner wanted total control of his opera: he wrote the words, he wrote the music, he was involved in staging and lighting, he even created a performance space where only his operas would be shown. This place still exists in Bayreuth, Germany, and the Bayreuth Festival celebrating Wagner still continues.

  • Waltraud Meier performs in Wagner’s “Tristan und Isolde,” La Scala, 2007

The unending melody

Wagner was influenced by the philosophy of the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer, who believed that man is motivated by an unrequited desire that will only ever be unsatisfied.

One compositional technique Wagner used to illustrate this idea is called “the unending melody,” Lumpkin explained.

In music, there are musical moments called cadences. If you think of a musical phrase as analogous to a sentence, cadences act as punctuation marks. Usually, a cadence acts as a period at the end of a musical sentence.

The Tristan chord

One of the most famous cadential moments in Wagner’s oeuvre, and in Western classical music, is called the Tristan chord because it occurs extensively in Wagner’s opera Tristan und Isolde.

“This chord, in and of itself, is not new,” Lumpkin explained. “Beethoven used it, Mozart used it, but it was always within a sort of cadential structure … in this moment it is very unprepared and unstable.”

What Wagner did that was new and different and exciting — and the reason the chord bears his opera’s name — was that he veered from that prescribed path.

Instead of resolving the chord to a resting point as Beethoven or Mozart might have done, Wagner left the Tristan chord unresolved. By doing this, Wagner created the feeling of unrequited longing, which is a major theme in Tristan und Isolde, and in Wagner’s works more generally.


Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
  • Dan Hortsch

    Thank you. I caught most but not all of this segment on the radio today. I enjoyed reading it all and having the videos. One suggestion: It would be nice to know who the singers are, and perhaps when and where the productions were.

    • Rachel Rohr, Here & Now

      Hi Dan, Thanks for your comment — we just added that info. You can see additional information about each video by clicking the video’s headline, which takes you to YouTube. Thanks for reading/listening! -Rachel Rohr/Web Producer

  • weini94


  • sdavidweaver

    I’m sure others have commented, but Verdi made many very positive comments on Wagner’s music. He said regarding Tristan: “I tremble before Tristan.” 

    Wagner’s comments, or lack of, regarding Verdi are well known. On the great Requiem, Wagner supposedly said: “…it’s best to say nothing”. 

  • Greg Johnson

    I got a perfect score on a critique of my first opera since Bugs Bunny as a child. My older brother shared a video by Anna Netrebko, and I watched her perform La Traviata with moving appreciation. I found this article as I prepare for a chapter quiz and exam on operas, and the info is fantastic (including previous comments!). Thank you sincerely.

Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

August 28 Comment

Catching Up With The Polyphonic Spree

The choral rock band out of Dallas, Texas, has been thrilling audiences with its live performances for over a decade.

August 28 5 Comments

‘Enormous’ Growth Of Ocean Garbage Patch

The oceanographer who discovered the floating island of trash in 1997 says he's shocked by how much it's grown.

August 27 Comment

Veteran Honored, But Struggles To Keep Business Open

Former Marine Matt Victoriano is being recognized as a "Champion of Change" at the White House.

August 27 40 Comments

In Defense Of Schlock Music: Why We Love/Hate It

Music critic Jody Rosen defends the kind of over-the-top, sentimental songs that Journey, Lionel Richie, Billy Joel and Prince made famous.