We hear a counterargument to our conversation earlier this week about how to accommodate transgender people in gyms.
This year’s Mount Everest climbing season has already been marked by conflict. A fight that broke out between Western climbers and Sherpa guides last month has been the buzz of the mountaineering world.
Climber Peter Athans has stood at the summit of Mount Everest seven times. He’s also guided many expeditions and has ties to the Sherpa community.
He says incidents of fighting are very rare.
“With this route crowding, with the issues of timing … it just puts the entire community there at an extreme amount of risk.”
“We don’t see this type of behavior on Everest that much,” Athans told Here & Now. “You’re an ambassador from your own country, and this is a place that sees hundreds of travelers at this time of the year. If you choose to, and want to have ultimate liberty at high altitude in an extreme environment, there are other places you could choose to go.”
What is more important and troubling, Athans said, is the overcrowding on the route, which can only accommodate a trickle of climbers.
Waiting along the dangerous, exposed route — whether to climb up or down — creates hazards and anxiety among climbers.
“I mean, you can imagine what it’s like to be waiting at the top of the Hillary step [a near-vertical rock face], above 28,000 feet, and you have a team of 100 people who are moving up through to go to the summit.”
In addition, because the window to reach the summit is so short, the gridlock makes climbing Everest extremely dangerous.
“With this route crowding, with the issues of timing, only having a limited number of resources to complete one’s climb, it just puts the entire community there at an extreme amount of risk,” Athans said.
The commercialization of Everest also invites people who feel overconfident about their abilities and are drawn to the rarified air without considering the possibility of failing to summit.
“You put out to the world that you’re going to go on and take on this objective, and it’s a huge amount of time away from family, from work, and it’s a large amount of money, it’s a large amount of psychological energy, preparation physically,” Athans said, “So sometimes getting to the top of the mountain is the most critical thing, and getting back down is the last thing on your mind.”
But summiting Everest remains one of the more profound and exclusive clubs a person can belong to.
“The quality of light is completely different,” Athans said of standing on the summit. “It’s very, very bright. It’s almost surreal. And if you’re lucky and blessed enough to be on top when there’s a beautiful day, you just see the world spread out beneath you.”