90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
PLEDGE NOW
Here and Now with Robin Young
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Friday, March 15, 2013

Could Botox Shots Help Depression?

The muscle in the eyebrow is the strongest means of expressing anger or sadness. (Image from "The Face of Emotion" by Eric Finzi).

The muscle in the eyebrow is the strongest means of expressing anger or sadness. (Image from “The Face of Emotion” by Eric Finzi).

Our facial expressions reflect how we feel. But for many years, researchers have theorized that the opposite can also be true – that making a particular facial expression can affect mood.

That’s the principle at play in dermatologist Eric Finzi’s new book “Face of Emotion: How Botox Affects Our Moods and Relationships(excerpt below).

Through some preliminary studies, Finzi and other researchers have found that that injecting Botox into muscles that are involved in frowning can help to elevate mood.

Finzi suggests that Botox treatments might help those suffering from severe depression.

“There are millions of people who are depressed, who’ve tried anti-depressants and talk therapy,” Finzi told Here & Now’s Robin Young. “Some of them may have even tried shock therapy. And for those people, if it helps them, this would be great to have one more tool in the little toolkit box of the physician to help them.”

Book Excerpt: Face of Emotion

By: Eric Finzi

The Face of Emotion book cover

(printer friendly/pdf)

Chapter 1: A poison to some, a miracle to others

What is now proved was once only imagined.
—William Blake

We are bombarded on a daily basis with flawless images of women and men. Whether these images are real or enhanced digitally and/or surgically, the young movie stars and models become idols whose looks and actions are emulated by millions. From style to parenting to cosmetic procedures, these demigods provide an elusive standard to which many aspire.

The desire to look like these icons goes hand in hand with the wish to prevent or reverse the ravages of aging, a part of human behavior for as long as we have had records. For millennia we have searched for simple, quick, and effective ways of treating aging. Today, Botox has become the most popular cosmetic procedure in the world. What attributes of Botox account for its immense popularity?

Perhaps it is because Botox injections are quick, affordable (as cosmetic procedures go), almost painless, and effective at reducing lines and wrinkles. In addition, treatment with Botox is non-invasive, is safe, causes minimal bruising, and requires only a short recovery period. All of these features add up to a drug used by millions.

How surprising then is the vitriolic reaction that the discussion of Botox can elicit! What is it about this molecule that brings out big partisan guns at the dinner table? How many other small proteins have such strong emotions attached to them?

Dr. Eric Finzi is author of "The Face of Emotion." He's pictured in front of one of his paintings (he's also an artist).

Dr. Eric Finzi is author of “The Face of Emotion.” He’s pictured in front of one of his paintings (he’s also an artist).

What Is Botox?

Botox is a trademarked name for one type of chemical whose scientific name is botulinum toxin A. It is derived from a bacterium that lives best under conditions where there is no oxygen. Before there were safety standards for the canning of food, it was not rare for people to die from the ingestion of this bacteria and its toxin after eating a can of improperly prepared food. Botulinum toxin is the most powerful poison made by nature. A single gram of the purified toxin, widely dispersed and inhaled, could kill a million people.

How Botox Was Discovered

In 1822, Justinus Kerner published his insights on the clinical course of botulism, including physical findings such as lack of tear fluid and muscle paralysis. Amazingly enough, he also speculated on the potential therapeutic value of botulinum toxin, including its possible use to prevent abnormal muscle movements. Subsequently, the bacterium responsible for botulism was identified and cultured. Long before any of the current uses, research was focused on purifying the toxin for use in warfare. Fortunately, botulinum toxin did not prove to be an easily applied weapon; it was more suited as a medicine. It wasn’t until 1973, when Dr. Alan Scott first published his work on the treatment of strabismus (a disorder in which the eyes are not properly aligned with one another, usually resulting from a lack of coordination from muscles controlling eye movements) in monkeys with botulinum toxin, that the possibilities for botulinum toxin being used medically began to be explored.

Botulinum toxin’s cosmetic uses were discovered when Jean Carruthers, a Canadian ophthalmologist, was treating a patient in 1987 for a rare eye disorder known as blepharospasm that causes excessive blinking of the eyes and, in some, causes the eyelids to slam shut. Dr. Carruthers treated the woman with botulinum toxin, then a largely unknown substance. Application of botulinum toxin in small amounts worked well and stopped Dr. Carruthers’s patient’s debilitating eye disorder. But, even with no symptoms, the patient kept coming back, telling her doctor that each time she received a botulinum toxin injection, the wrinkles between her brows seemed to disappear, giving her a relaxed, untroubled expression.

Dr. Carruthers’s husband, Alastair, a dermatologist, found the story of the blepharospasm patient intriguing and began to explore how botulinum toxin could be used to enhance a person’s appearance. Alastair and Jean’s seminal research helped bring botulinum toxin into wide usage. Since then, millions have been treated with botulinum toxin for both cosmetic and non-cosmetic reasons.

The toxin prevents neurons from releasing the chemical that allows us to use our muscles. A tiny amount prevents muscles from performing their normal duties, such as swallowing and breathing. If you ingest enough of the toxin, it paralyzes all the muscles in your body, including the ones necessary for moving the diaphragm, which is a required part of breathing. Unless you are hooked up to a breathing machine, you do not survive long after ingesting that bad can of food. In the 1800s, eating a contaminated sausage would cause a slow and agonizing death as one’s whole body became progressively weaker until, finally, one was unable to breathe. But injected locally, in tiny doses, the toxin paralyzes only a small area of muscle. The effect is temporary, lasting 3 to 12 months depending on where it is injected. In the face it is usually injected into the upper third to diminish forehead lines, crow’s feet, and frowning between the eyebrows. Any lines on the face that are caused by underlying facial muscle movement are helped by Botox. The ability to smile with your mouth is not affected, and you look younger from the softening of lines and creases and the absence of a scowl between your eyebrows.

It sounds pretty nasty that you are injecting a poison—until you realize that almost all drugs, in the wrong dose, are poisons. What really matters is the difference between the effective and lethal doses of the drug. The bigger the difference, the safer the drug. Conversely, if there is not much distinction between the dangerous and the effective dose, one must be very careful. Let us take the example of the drug acetaminophen, known most commonly by its brand name Tylenol. It is a safe drug when used properly, as evidenced by the millions of children who take it every year (who would give a poison to their child?). But what happens if you ingest ten times as many Tylenol as recommended? This is one of the more common reasons that young people require liver transplantation.

Or how about trying to push away some anxiety with a few Valium and a couple of drinks to further numb the pain? Another very bad idea. This sort of combination has accidently killed quite a few in Hollywood because the ratio between the lethal dose and the effective dose of anti-anxiety pills is not very high to begin with and is lowered significantly when combined with alcohol. Quite a few drugs have dangerous interactions with other medicines that can alter their safety profile. Botox is not among them. The difference between effective and lethal doses of botulinum toxin is huge.

If someone accidentally injected 20 times as much botulinum toxin as needed into your face, it would not kill you (although your face would look frozen). The fact that botulinum toxin is such a powerful and specific poison actually makes it a relatively safer drug. If you take 20 times the proper dose of aspirin, the pain in your shoulder may go away only to be replaced by more severe stomach pain caused by a bleeding ulcer, one of the unfortunate side effects of aspirin. In order for aspirin to help your shoulder, it needs to enter your bloodstream. But for it to get there, you need to eat it. And 20 pills can make quite a hole in your stomach.

Excerpted from the book THE FACE OF EMOTION by Eric Finzi, MD. Copyright © 2013 by Eric Finzi, MD, and reprinted with permission of Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Ltd.

Guest:

  • Eric Finzi, dermatologist and author or “Face of Emotion.” He’s also president of two dermatology practices in Maryland.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
  • dwt

    Is Paul Thomas Anderson on today? (Mar 15.)

  • Raoul Ornelas

    Speaker John Boehner and Mitch McConnell need Botox!

  • Lynda Adelson

    I don’t know about botox, but I have been severely depressed since I was a teenager and the ONLY thing that has really helped me is Ritilan, prescribed off label. It’s been a god send for me.

  • JonjayOak12

    I love how Robin only asks soft ball questions and the only real question she answers herself lol. I guess journalism is dead.

  • mjones

    People who work in spiritual fields have known for a long time that facial expressions and posture can affect moods. Its great to have that confirmed by scientific studies. But why jump right to injecting a toxic chemical rather before learning a practice to change expressions and posture? It would be much cheaper and certainly self-empowering, for most people if not all. The medical model so often takes the power for healing out of the hands of the individual and puts it into the hands of drug companies.

  • http://depressionwithoutmedication.blogspot.com/2013/03/living-with-depression-can-trigger.html depression without medication

    Depression is a very serious illness that cannot be treated with Botox, many are seeking ways to handle depression without anti depressants due to the side effects

  • davee44

    Depression and Self harm cutting is increasing at a rapid rate among young people 
    http://stopcuttingyourself.blogspot.com/2013/03/cutting-and-depressed-is-sad-combination.html

  • http://www.tomkins.org/ Susan Leigh Deppe, MD

    Very interesting confirmation of the body feedback loops we’ve been talking about for many years in the Tomkins Institute. Silvan Tomkins called the face the display board for the affect system. The affects (the accent is on the first syllable) are innate emotional programs with distinct emotional experiences and facial displays. Another example of that somatosensory feedback:  How many times have you felt your face growing red in embarrassment, which seemed to make you even more embarrassed?
     
    I appreciate the fact that Dr. Finzi puts Botox into perspective as a possible future adjunct treatment for depression, but as only one possible tool in the toolbox. I also agree with the comment by ‘mjones’ above, who suggests that in some cases we might teach people practices that enable them to accomplish the same things without medications or injections.
     
    Thanks for broadcasting this story.
     
    Susan Leigh Deppe, MD, DFAPA
    Psychiatry, Colchester, Vermont
    Twitter:  @Emotiondoc
    Faculty, the Tomkins Institute:  Applied Studies in Motivation, Emotion, and Cognition  www.tomkins.org
    and
    Clinical Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, the University of Vermont College of Medicine
    Private Practice, Colchester, Vermont   

  • Eric Nichols

    this is the biggest load of horse sh*t I have read in a very long time…

Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

September 16 7 Comments

Kathy Gunst Explores Community Supported Agriculture

Kathy Gunst joins Cook's Illustrated executive food editor Keith Dresser at his CSA pickup and offers recipes for the seasonal CSA fare.

September 16 11 Comments

Remembering Jesse Winchester

Jimmy Buffett remembers his friend the late songwriter Jesse Winchester, whose posthumous album is being released today.

September 15 26 Comments

A Call To Reject Corporal Punishment As Part Of Black Culture

An incident of child abuse by an NFL player has raised questions about the use of corporal punishment as a form of discipline in the African-American community.

September 15 26 Comments

Would You Pay To Get Your Kid Into A Top College?

A San Francisco company charges parents for a consulting package based on the odds their student will get into a certain university, with prices up to a million dollars.