PLEDGE NOW
Here and Now with Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Friday, February 22, 2013

Up For Oscars, But Historically Inaccurate?

"Argo" actor and director Ben Affleck is pictured in a still from the film. (Warner Bros.)

“Argo” actor and director Ben Affleck is pictured in a still from the film. (Warner Bros.)

At this Sunday’s Oscars, “Argo,” “Lincoln” and “Zero Dark Thirty” are all up for Best Picture.

But though they’re all based on real-life events, all three films have drawn criticism for playing somewhat loose with history.

“Argo” has a dramatic scene in a Tehran market, as well as a car chase scene in the climax of the film – both of which didn’t happen in real life.

“Lincoln,” which portrays the struggle in Congress to pass the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery, shows Connecticut legislators voting against the Amendment, which also did not happen.

And there has been a continuing controversy over “Zero Dark Thirty,” which contains harsh interrogation scenes, and has been accused of implying that harsh interrogation yielded the information that led to the killing of Osama Bin Laden.

As the headline of a recent Boston Globe editorial says, “In teaching history, Hollywood isn’t as good as high school.”

Peter Canellos, the Globe’s editorial page editor, tells Here & Now’s Robin Young that film goers need to go into these movies with a sense of skepticism. But he also says that filmmakers have a a responsibility to history.

“They have to be true to the overall narrative, and that’s where ‘Zero Dark Thirty’ has a problem. If it’s in fact not true that torture played any role in amassing the evidence that led to Osama Bin Laden, and they suggest that it did, then that’s just violating the core narrative. That’s not just putting the Connecticut congressman on the wrong side of the issue,” Canellos said.

Jimmy Carter talks about “Argo” on CNN:

Guest:


Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
Spotlight

Peter O’Dowd follows the route of Abraham Lincoln's funeral train 150 years ago, to look at modern-day race relations and Lincoln's legacy.

Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

May 1 Comment

Lincoln History Told Through Tree Rings

At President Abraham Lincoln's funeral in 1865, the oak tree stood just a few feet from the event, shading the funeral choir.

May 1 Comment

Chigozie Obioma Makes A Splash With Debut Novel

"The Fishermen" is earning raves in the literary world and drawing comparisons to the late Chinua Achebe.

April 30 Comment

Lincoln’s Legacy Inspires Greek Family Business In Decatur

Our Tracking Lincoln series continues with the third-generation owner of the Lincoln Square Lounge.

April 29 Comment

Placebo Effect: It Might Not Be In Your Head After All

There's new evidence that what's going on with the placebo effect is more than psychological. The implications are numerous.