Here and Now with Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson
Public radio's live
midday news program
With sponsorship from
Mathworks - Accelerating the pace of engineering and science
Accelerating the pace
of engineering and science
Thursday, January 12, 2012

Facebook’s Suicide Prevention Tool Raises Privacy Concerns


The mother and sister of a Staten Island teen who recently committed suicide are taking to the site to express anger at the bullies they blame for pushing 15-year-old Amanda Cummings over the edge in December.

Facebook is also where Cummings apparently had been hinting at her problems and depression.

Should Facebook have intervened?

Facebook says it is trying to help users who may be feeling suicidal. The site has a new tool aimed at getting those considering suicide help.

“The new service enables Facebook users to report a suicidal comment they see posted by a friend to Facebook using either the Report Suicidal Content link or the report links found throughout the site,” wrote U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Regina Benjamin in a post on Facebook’s Safety Blog.

Privacy Concerns

But some are concerned that Facebook users privacy may be compromised.

Psychologist John Grohol says Facebook’s service is an important service, but he has concerns. “It’s a well-intentioned effort, [but] it needs to be refined,” he told Here & Now‘s Robin Young.

Grohol says that most people who signed up for Facebook did not sign up for Facebook with the expectation that it was a health mental service.

He writes Facebook “is suddenly your very own paternalistic health buddy.” He continues:

In the world of mental health, even the fact that you’re seeing a mental health provider is considered privileged health information… By sending a well-intended email to the user’s private email account, Facebook is exposing your email account to personal health information that I doubt most Facebook users ever imagined Facebook would be providing. In this case, the personal health information is that you are someone who may be depressed, suicidal and in crisis. In most cases, the assumptions that Facebook and Lifeline have made about a person’s email are probably accurate — that a person’s email is private. But in some small minority of cases, that may not be the case. The email address may be shared, or it may be monitored by a concerned parent (or by a nosy spouse or partner).


  • John Grohol, a psychologist and expert on online mental health services, also founder of perspectives: a mental health magazine and founder of

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
Robin and Jeremy

Robin Young and Jeremy Hobson host Here & Now, a live two-hour production of NPR and WBUR Boston.

October 7 209 Comments

Lawsuit Challenges Transgender Locker Room Access At Planet Fitness

We hear a counterargument to our conversation earlier this week about how to accommodate transgender people in gyms.

October 7 12 Comments

‘I Drive Your Truck’ Songwriter Now Drives Her Brother’s Truck

Like the real-life story that inspired her hit song, Connie Harrington now drives a pickup truck to remember a loved one who died.

October 6 53 Comments

Former Sandy Hook Teacher On Moving Forward After Tragedy

Kaitlin Roig-Debellis explains how she worked through her grief after the tragic shooting in her new book "Choosing Hope."

October 2 5 Comments

Study: Chemo Unnecessary In Many Cases Of Early-Stage Breast Cancer

A new study finds that many women with early stage breast cancer don't benefit from chemotherapy.